A ramble through the mind of a murderer - Tactical Ninja
Jul. 18th, 2012
09:52 am - A ramble through the mind of a murderer
Apparently that nice Mr Key wants to know personally what I think. He does! He sent me a printed ticky-box form letter saying "How can we make a brighter future for you?" and the return address is directly to him! So since I now have a personal and direct line to the prime minister, I filled in the form for him. Because aw, he cares!
I may have taken some liberties with the wording of the three issues that were important to me, which are now worded thus:
1. Reducing long-term welfare dependency, with a focus on
work job creation.
Selling minority Keeping all shares in four all energy SOEs and Air New Zealand.
3. Practical environmental policies supporting sustainable growth and greener technology.
In 'important local issues' I wrote The way that since this government was elected, many of my friends have lost their jobs due to redundancy and there seems nothing is in place to support new job creation.
Because fuckit, he asked. I'm sure he'll address my concerns personally too.
The first Crim lecture was yesterday. The lecturer was the same guy who was my tutor way back when I was doing 100-level Sociology as a prerequisite. I remember being That Student who talked in tutorials and being new enough to feel as if I was being a wanker because of it. I ended up liking this guy a lot. He recommended The Sociological Imagination to me when I was having trouble getting to grips with the abstract nature of social theory, and it helped. And he's passionate, even though he's obviously been at it a really long time. He also reminds me a lot of my Dad, being English, bearded and older.
Anyway, he's into theory and wants us all to be as well, and to give us some idea of how theory could be interesting, he showed us the video of a police interview conducted on a guy who had just shot two men in a pub at point blank range, seemingly unprovoked. He'd walked into the pub, looked around, then gone out to his car, got two guns, gone back in and killed the two men. He then shot up the gambling machines, offered to buy everyone a drink, then went outside, smoked a joint, went back in and shot up some more gambling machines. Then he went to his girlfriends' parents place where the police later picked him up.
At the start of the interview he was obviously still stoned. He talks like a bro. Most people probably don't know what that means, so here's a handy 50 second video by the late great Billy T James to demonstrate:
Billy T was taking the piss but this is an actual dialect in NZ, and while Billy T totally reclaimed it, the reality is that this accent says a fair bit about socio-economic status - the lower end of it. It used to be mainly a Maori dialect (apparently the inflections are the same as you would use when speaking Maori), but it has come to be spoken by some pakeha as well. My husband talked like it when he was with his mates, although he didn't when talking to, say, his parents or tradespeople or clients.
Anyway, this guy was a good looking young Maori man with dreadlocks, talked like a bro, was obviously stoned, and seemed not interested in taking any responsibility for what he'd done. He said that one of the victims (the publican) had banned him from the pub for a fight he didn't start, and that the other guy had 'stabbed him in the back', that the 'rich cunts'* saw him being homeless and did nothing. That people laughed at him, that the government had it in for him, that he was 'whacking his missus' and that he blamed the people who crapped on him for him taking it out on her. He said he wanted to go back to jail because at least he was welcome there. That killing the two men was "I done what I said I'd do."
Throughout, he showed no remorse for his actions and it's clear that he was so removed from the values and norms of average society that he didn't see what he did as being something to be upset about.
The questions we were asked after watching this were along the lines of "What do you do with people like this?" the implication being that how we feel about what we'd just seen probably has a theory attached to it, and that these theories can be analysed in terms of what they say about human nature, the social order, definitions of crime, extent of crime in a society, causes of crime, and policy solutions. So if you think the young guy is wrong in the head, then you might look at a positivist theory for a solution. If you don't care about him and only care about what he did, you'd be looking at a classicist or conservative theory, depending on your view of how he should be dealt with.
Except for me, because this young man reminded me of my ex husband so much, not only in his speech but his mannerisms, the thing that screamed out to me from the video was that everything he said and did was about power. The hitting his missus, the little plays where he refuses to tell the policeman information about his home and about the colour of his car, the accusations levelled against the two victims who had exerted power over him either by banning him from the pub or by laughing at his homelessness. There's a bit in the video where he taunts the police officer, who had searched his house months earlier looking for stolen weapons and not found them, with the idea that one of the guns used was one of the ones he'd been looking for. He later says he found the guns next to a house. I saw this as another power play - "I got one over you all those months ago and now look." The way he assumes a powerful posture and mimes killing the two men - it looks like he's imagining himself as the Terminator or some other powerful bringer of vengeance as he does it. Pretty much everything the young guy says and does is a power play of some kind.
Which leads me to believe that in this particular case, the murder of the two men was also about power. About someone who spends their life feeling powerless and doing anything they can to feel as if they are in control, reaching a point where having power is more important that living within social norms. I'm not saying what he did was justified. Obviously it wasn't - you don't kill people for banning you from a pub for fighting ffs. But when you look at the situation from a perspective of the power dynamics in the young guy's life, it makes it a lot easier to understand how he might end up with a set of values so far from normal that he can rationalise shooting people.
What this means (apart from that I think I've witnessed too much power-based rationalisation in my life) is that my view of this situation is apparently in the Critical school, which views crime in terms of the influences of power relationships within a society rather than in terms of rational choice or deviance from norms or pre-determined personal traits. Colour me completely unsurprised by that! So yeah, the video had the desired effect - it got me thinking about theory and how it might apply to tricky situations. And for me, it's kind of personal. Normally I'm pretty liberal-viewed in that I think punishing people by imprisoning them and then throwing them out on the street with 'convict' stamped all over their life is not an appropriate way to deal with crime and that support and assistance to achieve the things that help you have a 'normal' life within society is more likely to make a real difference. But I always devil's-advocate myself with my ex-husband. What do you do with people like him? I've never had an answer for that which makes me question the consistency of my worldview. Now I think maybe this theory business will help me find one.
A year later, Stephen Matchitt was dead, stabbed to death in a cell block in Paremoremo prison.
* In New Zealand, 'cunt' is normally used to refer to men, and in this dialect has all the impact of 'bloke' or 'dude' - it's not really an insult used this way.
So anyway, watching that video took me back to my past (again) in some pretty deep (but luckily not too distressing) ways. Consequently, last night I dreamed I was rousieing on a raised board, and the shearer I was working with's wife came in and got all shitty at me because I was rousieing too well and she though her husband might start to fancy me because of my Mad Skilllz.
Yes seriously, it was like that. Sorting fribs to catch yourself a man, oh please can I?
Have I mentioned lately how glad I am that I'm not there any more?